IP & Competition Henry Quentir IP & Competition Henry Quentir

New York City's $29.2 Million QFab Award to NYU, Announced 14 October 2026: How the City's 15% Share of Quantum IP Proceeds and Three Advisory Seats Would Work

What New York City and NYU announced on 14 October 2026

Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani, Deputy Mayor for Economic Justice Julie Su and NYCEDC chief executive Anthony Shorris announced that the city will award $29.2 million to New York University for QFab, a quantum fabrication facility of 23,000 square feet at 770 Broadway. NYU adds $255 million for construction and ten years of operations. The facility is expected to open in 2030 with cleanrooms, cryogenics and equipment for making and testing quantum chips and components, open to researchers, students, startups and established companies.

What the city receives in return for its quantum investment

The city gets three seats on the QFab Executive Advisory Board. When intellectual property is created at QFab using tools the city funded, it also receives 15% of NYU Central Administration's proceeds from that IP, including equity, royalties, milestone payments and patent licenses. The city calls this a first-of-its-kind agreement. Read closely, the 15% applies to one slice of one revenue stream. This post reconstructs the deal from the public announcement, compares it with the federal Bayh-Dole rules of 1980 and the US government's passive 9.9% Intel stake of 2025, and lists what the unpublished agreement still has to settle.

Read More
IP & Competition Henry Quentir IP & Competition Henry Quentir

Third Circuit Rules in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS on 29 September 2026: Training a Legal AI on 2,243 Westlaw Headnotes Was Not Fair Use

What the Third Circuit decided on 29 September 2026

In Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Intelligence, No. 25-2153, a Third Circuit panel of Judges Restrepo, Montgomery-Reeves and Bove affirmed partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters. Judge Montgomery-Reeves wrote the precedential opinion. It holds that 2,243 Westlaw headnotes are original works and that ROSS's use of them to train its AI legal search engine was not fair use under 17 U.S.C. 107. ROSS had commissioned about 25,000 training memos built with the help of the headnotes, and it marketed the finished product as a substitute for Westlaw at comparable prices.

Why the intermediate-copying defense failed

ROSS argued that training is an intermediate step, protected like the code copying in Google v. Oracle, Sega and Connectix. The court read those cases as resting on necessity: copying was the only route to unprotected functional elements. ROSS had free access to the judicial opinions themselves and chose the headnotes because they were easier to use. The court also held that each headnote is a separate work, so every one copied was a whole work taken.

Which market the court protected

On the fourth factor the court found that a market for licensing headnotes as AI training data is rapidly developing, and that ROSS's copying usurped Thomson Reuters's chance to enter it. The opinion addresses a non-generative system and expressly leaves the generative-AI cases, including the pending OpenAI litigation in New York, to their own facts.

Read More